This article describes old and new approaches to interpreting contracts, and then recounts the rules of contract interpretation that are gener. That analytical approach comfortably fits this case as well. The most interesting opinion of the four is judge plagers concurring opinion that focuses on the intentional ambiguity inserted into the claims by 3m. Parties can contract around the contra proferentum rule 42 5. Frequently, courts hold that ambiguities in a contract are to be interpreted against the party who prepared the agreement, on the theory that the drafter should have been more precise in phrasing the contract in order to clearly inform the other party of his intent.
A contract must be so interpreted as to give effect to the mutual intention of the parties as it existed at the time of contracting, so far as the same is ascertainable and lawful. No provision of this agreement or any related document will be construed against or interpreted to the disadvantage of any party hereto by any court or other governmental or judicial authority by reason of such party having or being deemed to have structured or drafted such provision. This contract clause says that any ambiguous language in the contract shall be interpreted according to its fair meaning and not strictly for or against any party. Now, while we dont know who the drafter of the contract here is for sure, it is safe to say that the times square restaurant would have drafted the. Implied terms in some cases, a court will imply a term to cover a situation for which the parties failed to provide or, when needed, to give the contract a construction or meaning that is reasonable. Judge plager argues that courts should begin to apply the contract doctrine of contra proferentem and construe ambiguous terms against the drafter i. One the one hand the specification called for the site establishment for the employer and engineer to be provided to the end of the contract, which could be construed as meaning the end of the defects liability period and on the other hand the bill of. Hopefully this book will help young legal professionals understand that many contract.
Finally, many jurisdictions hold that contract ambiguities are construed against the drafter of the document, especially if the application of other. In ordinary noninsurance contract litigation, the contra proferentem doctrine is often used as a last resort to resolve ambiguous contract language or, as one commentator put it, a lateinning. Are vagueambiguous contract provisions always construed. Such disagreement by the parties may be based on real confusion or an effort by a party to. Lawyers like to provide certainty on how a contract must be and will be interpreted. Furthermore, contracts between spouses are interpreted under the same rules for interpreting any other contract. For the purpose of ascertaining the intention of the parties to a contract, if otherwise doubtful, the rules given in this chapter are to be applied. Jan 01, 2020 another principle of contract interpretation is the concept of contra proferentem. Construing the contract against the drafter lambert law. Statutory guidelines on contract interpretation weagree. Amendments to standard jury instructions in contract and. How to get out of a contract illinois defenses to breach.
As a general proposition, except for those contracts which, as a matter of law and validity, must be in writing,0 a contract need not be in writing to be enforceable. Beware of unclear language in construction contractsforms. The interpretation rules suggest that a very onesided contract may be highly susceptible of being interpreted against the drafter. Contracts should be construed in a commercially reasonable. Each party recognizes that this agreement is a legally binding contract and acknowledges that such party has had the opportunity to consult with legal counsel of choice. Dd 1228 should ambiguity run against drafter in commercial. The contra proferentem rule whereas ambiguity goes against the drafter or party that sought inclusion of the ambiguous term contract law, provincial offences, employment law, tort law and criminal law. The editor is uncomfortable with application to commercial real estate contracts of the rule that ambiguities in contracts should be interpreted against the drafter. For me it was a good move to hire a lawyer to look over my book publishing contract, for these two reasons. Moreover, unless the parties have contemplated otherwise, the contract need not be in a certain form. The latin term contra proferentem is a contract principle that provides that an ambiguous or uncertain term in a contract will be construed against the party that caused the uncertainty to exist.
Plus, contracting parties sometimes opt out of, or expressly invoke, various statutory or common law rules. Study the two examples below in the model contracts handbook. When a term is ambiguous, a crystal ball matter, the ambiguity should be construed against the. Under those circumstances, final rule for interpreting the contract is the construction against drafter doctrine. Protect laypeople from the dangers of form contracts that they have little power to change. If you learned from this post, think about how much more you could learn from the book. When your new york contract is unclear law offices of. What happens when a particular provision within a contract is unclear or, better yet if the contract doesnt even address it at all. How to get out of a contract illinois defenses to breach of. In any construction of the terms of this agreement, the same shall not be construed against either party on the basis of that party being the drafter of such terms. Generally, the language of a contract is to be construed against its drafter. Any ambiguity in insurance contract must be interpreted against drafting.
Ambiguities in the contract will be interpreted against the drafter, especially where the drafter has superior bargaining power. Plain meaning, parol evidence and use of the just result principle harry g. Jdr coachworks, 2005 canlii 6374 at paragraphs 22 to 23 as follows. Interestingly, williston suggests that contra proferentemthe rule that ambiguities are to be interpreted against the drafteris a rule of interpretation, since it should be anticipated that the person addressed will understand ambiguous language in the sense most favorable to himself, and that his reasonable understanding should.
If this formidable hurdle is overcome, the courts will first turn to a host of rules pertaining to contract interpretation which can fill up entire chapters in legal texts. Why unclear contract provisions go against the drafter under ny law this question comes up all the time. Under certain circumstances, ambiguous terms are generally construed against the drafter of the contract. May 01, 2015 if contract is ambiguous, then it will be construed against drafter. Anytime you see the elements of something or the requirements of something or the rule, write it down and remember it because its likely to be on the exam. The contra proferentem rule whereas ambiguity goes against. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Agreement and plan of merger no construction against drafter. Please use the navigation bar on the left to move around this book. Part of the consumer protection law commons, contracts commons, courts commons, and the. The committee has been unable to find case law authority applying this principle when the contract contains language stating the contract will not be interpreted against the drafter. At least two other federal courts of appeal have agreed. For example a provision requiring only one party of a contract to pay attorney fees if it loses in litigation may be applied to both parties by the courts.
The latin term contra proferentem translates as against the offerer and is used in law as a principle stating that where a contract contains an ambiguous term, that term should be interpreted against the party that proffered the term. If the parties cannot agree in the drafting stage as to definitions, then it is good to. When a term is ambiguous, a crystal ball matter, the ambiguity should be. Court split over contra proferentem doctrine widens law360. Why unclear contract provisions go against the drafter under. Since the agreement in question was prepared by the employer, the court cited the standard rule in contract law that any ambiguity is interpreted against the drafter the party preparing the document. However, construing a contract against the drafter to resolve ambiguous contract language called the rule of contra proferentem is applicable only if the intent of the parties cannot be discerned through the use of all conventional rules of interpretation, including. Drafting and negotiating commercial contracts and millions of other books are available for amazon kindle.
When the language has more than one meaning, it will be interpreted against the party who drafted the contract. Another principle of contract interpretation is the concept of contra proferentem. Contra proferentem is a rule of contract law stating that where a contract contains an ambiguous term, the terms should be interpreted against the drafter of the contract or the party that pushed for inclusion of the ambiguous term the legal principle of contra proferentem is a latin term meaning against the offerer and is used in law to. Rather than find against the drafter, they would determine the intent of the parties and would interpret the contract and any inconsistencies in the contract according to that intent.
Acknowledging receipt of a document is not the same as. This agreement cannot be canceled, altered or amended except in writing and signed by both parties. The courts will also look to how the parties interpreted that contract after they signed and began performance. Jul 02, 20 this would consider the negotiation history of the contract. Cases like thisclaim construction issues such as this onemay well deserve application of a principle analogous to the contract doctrine of contra proferentem. This agreement shall be interpreted according to its fair meaning and intent and not against the drafter of all or any provisions hereof.
Under these circumstances, buyer and seller agree that the rule of construction that a contract be construed against the drafter shall not be applied in interpreting this amendment and. Contra proferentem is a rule of contract interpretation that says ambiguous or conflicting terms within a contract should, generally, be construed against the party that drafted or proffered the ambiguous term. This section of the template includes general terms common to business contracts. Contract construction and interpretation by courts jay. A technique to diminish this is to improve the sense of mutuality of the contract provisions. The party relying upon construing the contract against the drafter runs the risk that the courts will find a way to reconcile the contract clauses. Each party has participated in negotiating and drafting this agreement, so if an ambiguity or a question of intent or interpretation arises, this agreement is to be construed as if the parties had drafted it jointly, as opposed to being construed against a party because it was responsible for drafting one or more provisions of this agreement. A whereas clause cannot create any rights arising from. The contra proferentem rule whereas ambiguity goes against the drafter or party that sought inclusion of the ambiguous term. Should either party cancel this book publishing contract, all rights granted to the publisher shall revert to the author.
To get around the interpretation against the drafter rule, some lawyers insert a clause into the contracts they draft that provides, in effect, the parties agree that no one party drafted this contract, but we both contributed to it, and, so, the interpretation against the drafter rule doesnt apply to this contract. The contra proferentem doctrine was articulated well in the case of cote v. Tenant acknowledges and agrees that it has read each of the terms of this lease and has had the opportunity to comment and negotiate such terms, and that, therefore, the lease shall not be construed in favor or against either party based on the fact that it was drafted by landlord. This is a good example of a conflict in the contract documents. Where two interpretations of contract are possible, court will prefer interpretation which gives meaning to both provisions rather than interpretation which renders one of the provisions meaningless. Paragraph titles are inserted for convenience only, and are not to be used to construe the provisions. May 01, 2017 the committee has been unable to find case law authority applying this principle when the contract contains language stating the contract will not be interpreted against the drafter. The parties hereto have participated jointly in the negotiation and drafting of this agreement and, in the event an. Judge plagers concurring opinion focuses on the intentional ambiguity inserted into the claims by 3m. An ambiguous contract is interpreted strictly against the party who drafted it. If the contract does not include a clause that aids in the interpretation of disputes.
This is particularly important if you draft the contract because ambiguities in a contract are typically construed against the drafter. Proposed standard jury instructions a contract and business. The uniform commercial code the basic structure book icon. In that case, the court isnt going to throw out the ambiguous provision or construe it against the drafter. Drafter of contract was bound by contracts unfavorable choice of law provision duarte, j. In cases of uncertainty not removed by the preceding rules, the language of a contract should be interpreted most strongly against the party who caused the uncertainty to exist. During my 30year contracts career, i have gradually developed a list of 60 practical contractdrafting tips. The doctrine says that, at the final step, as a tiebreaker, the jury should interpret the contract against the party that drafted the disputed words. Contra proferentem university of michigan law school. The doctrine is often applied to situations involving standardized. Implications of poorly drafted contract documents claims. As a refresher, i routinely refer to my tipsheet as well as other checklists just before i draft a contract. Contra proferentem is a rule of contract law stating that where a contract contains an ambiguous term, the terms should be interpreted against the drafter of the contract or the party that pushed for inclusion of the ambiguous term. Ambiguities are contract language that is difficult to comprehend or distinguish.
Thus the importance of default rules in contract law, which determine parties contractual obligation in the absence of evidence of their intent. Since the term was ambiguous, the argument went, it should be construed against the architectowner as the drafter of the contract documents, and the. A provision may be subject to multiple interpretations standing alone, but maybe only one of those interpretations makes sense in light of the rest of the contract. The interpretation rules suggest that a very onesided contract may be highly susceptible to being interpreted against the drafter.
I knew she would have a better idea about the royalty rates, for example, but. Har 1 lull in the court of appeals of the state of. Alternatively, the parties expressions of their intent might be ambiguous. Unlike form agreements in other consumer and commercial contexts, commercial real estate agreements are almost always studied and negotiated by the parties. If there is still ambiguity, you go to risk allocation rules, and there are three of them. Elliot enters into a contract to purchase jds house, and then changes her mind. Any ambiguity in insurance contract must be interpreted against drafting party and in favor of insured. Principles of contractual interpretation lsu law digital commons. Words in a contract which are wholly inconsistent with its nature, or with the main intention of the parties, are to be rejected. A technique to diminish this risk is to improve the sense of mutuality in the contract provisions. If the contract at issue or an applicable statute provides that the contract will not be construed against the drafter, the committee would suggest that this be. Any ambiguity is interpreted against the drafter of the contract. Har 1 lull in the court of appeals of the state of washington. If contract is ambiguous, then it will be construed against drafter.
Contract construction and interpretation by courts jay young. Why you should take your book publishing contracts to a lawyer. Under these circumstances, buyer and seller agree that the rule of construction that a contract be construed against the drafter shall not be applied in interpreting this amendment and that in the event of any ambiguity in any of the terms or conditions of this amendment, including any exhibits or schedules hereto and whether or not placed of record, such ambiguity shall not be construed for or against any party hereto on the basis that such party did or did not author same. For this reason, i compiled a list of books on contract drafting released in 2016. Mar, 2012 construing ambiguities against the drafter. Nov 01, 2019 for example a provision requiring only one party of a contract to pay attorney fees if it loses in litigation may be applied to both parties by the courts.
1252 740 1008 386 392 747 60 683 201 988 704 489 455 329 1154 221 259 1050 897 1364 1462 371 72 1007 1327 983 1307 366 60 1408 691 220 704 828